• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Barton's Pizzeria: The Heart of Highland's Pizza Scene

At Barton's Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on being a beloved staple in Highland, IN. Our story is steeped in community, where we serve up delicious pizzas that evoke nostalgia and comfort. Our menu features a range of dishes, from our signature homemade pizzas to tantalizing beef bowls and savory sandwiches. Customers frequently share heartfelt testimonials about their experiences, highlighting the warmth of our staff and the efficiency of our service. Whether it's a casual dinner or catering for a wedding, Barton's has become synonymous with quality and care. Visit us to taste the love we put into every bite!

Barton's Pizzeria at a glance

  • Address 3925 45th St, Highland, IN 46322
  • Phone (219) 924-6200
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Meal delivery .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner .

Photos & Gallery

Barton's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

jen kerr
5

Bartons has been my favorite pizza for over 45 years! I don't live in the area anymore but I make sure to stop in to grab a pizza to take with me whenever I'm in the area

Neil Z
5

It's become one of our favorite places for take-out - the garlic cheesy "breadsticks" (mini-pizza disguised as breadsticks) are awesome. Garlic parm fries are great.. pizza has a universally good blend with a not too greasy, not too bland thick snappy texture and just the right amount of cheese. Always predictably good!

Pete DeQuarto
5

Barton's was precisely what the doctor ordered today. Family-size Sausage Pizza was delicious, and was ready quicker than we could've made dinner! Can't wait to order again! The tomato bread sounds like it will be great too!

Sam Rodriguez
4

To start, I love Barton's, been going to the one on Calumet for over 30 years. I ordered from the Highland location since I live in Highland now. I ordered a sausage and and cheese, extra well done (I once had a severe case of food poisoning years ago so I try to make sure my food is thoroughly cooked)... Got my pizza home and it was baked like any other pizza, I called to discuss this with the woman that answered, I mentioned that I like my pizza very brown, just short of burning it, she was nice and asked if I could send her a picture of it to discuss this with her oven guy of 30 years. I sent her a picture cause she said she would call back, she never did. I told her that I love their pizza but now I can never order from them again.....

Kerri Mauch
5

This is our go to local pizza place. Their crust is a stand out. It is fluffy and crispy, a perfect combo.

Michele Gilbert
5

We travel from Lowell to Highland and have been going to Barton’s forever! We moved to Indiana from Connecticut 35 years ago and had the hardest time finding Pizza that reminded us of home. After trying place after place we stumbled upon Barton’s. and it’s been our pizza and calzone to-go place ever since! They are the best!

Diane
5

The staff exhibits a professional yet approachable demeanor. All menu items are consistently delicious, and order accuracy is consistently high. High-quality ingredients ensure food quality remains exceptional. The weekday specials are unbeatable. Ms. Nichole operates a truly exemplary pizza establishment that serves as a model for others in the industry.

Randi Whitmer
4

Found out today they have ' pizza by the slice ' Made it just the way I like it, along with the family's pizzas

Location

  • Barton's Pizzeria
    Barton's Pizzeria
    3925 45th St, Highland, IN 46322 Hotline: (219) 924-6200

Welcome to Barton's Pizzeria, a beloved culinary gem nestled in Highland, Indiana. Located at 3925 45th St, this pizza haven effortlessly brings the warmth of home cooking to the heart of the community. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, you’ll find yourself immersed in a dynamic atmosphere filled with the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizzas and the cheerful hustle of a dedicated team.

Barton's offers a plethora of options that cater to every craving. From their savory Chicken Tenders and BBQ Rib Dinners—complete with salad and garlic bread—to delightful sandwiches like the Italian Sausage and BBQ Beef, there's something to satisfy everyone. And let's not forget their beautifully crafted pizzas, which have garnered glowing reviews for being precisely what the doctor ordered for so many. Customers rave about the double neo and family-size sausage pizzas, which are not just meals, but experiences steeped in nostalgia and flavor.

The commitment to quality and customer service is evident. As one reviewer noted, “the staff is the best around,” and many customers have highlighted their impressive efficiency, even during busy times like Super Bowl Sunday. The team at Barton's goes above and beyond, ensuring that each pizza is ready right on time, making it an ideal choice for gatherings and celebrations, or even a cozy night in.

But Barton's Pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s about community. It's a space where memories are made over shared meals, and each bite feels like a display of love and care. The outdoor seating is perfect for enjoying the warm Indiana weather, making it an inviting spot for families and groups to unwind together.

If you’re looking for a pizza place that combines delicious food with a warm atmosphere and excellent service, Barton's Pizzeria is the destination for you. Join the ranks of satisfied diners and make your order at (219) 924-6200. Indulge in a slice of nostalgia and savor the flavors that have captured the hearts of countless customers.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards